Pizza is one of the most beloved dishes on the planet. Originally a working-class meal that appeared in Naples, Italy, in the 18th century, pizza has come a long way from its humble origins. You can now order pizzas with dozens, if not hundreds, of different toppings, so no matter what kind of pizza you want, there’s probably a nearby restaurant serving it.

Although Cape Cod isn’t necessarily known for its pizza, you’ll find delicious local spots in every town. These small establishments have the freedom to offer their own unique creations, which is great news if you’re looking for something a little different during your vacation.

You won’t have to travel far from your vacation rental to uncover a wonderful pie. Here’s a look at some of the best pizza restaurants on the Cape.

RC’s Cape Cod Pizza

Main Street in Yarmouth Port is a quiet, mostly residential area. However, as you get closer to Dennis, there’s a small commercial area featuring a couple of strip malls, including one with Peterson’s Market. It might be hard to believe as you approach, but inside Peterson’s Market is RC’s Cape Cod Pizza, one of the region’s best pizza restaurants.

RC’s Pizza makes all dough and sauce from scratch. The restaurant also has a unique cheese blend the staff mixes on-site, helping take these pizza creations to the next level. Popular menu items include the steak bomb, chicken deluxe, and house pizzas, which you can get as a 12-inch, 18-inch, or 25-inch monster pizza.

You can order chicken wings, burgers, subs, and sandwiches from RC’s, too, so even if you aren’t in the mood for a pizza, there’s plenty of reason to check out this Cape Cod original.

Stone L’Oven Pizza Brewster

Look no further than Stone L’Oven Pizza in Brewster for a hand-tossed, all-natural, artisan-crafted pizza. This establishment is located on Underpass Road, near the Cape Cod Rail Trail and Stony Brook Field, making it the perfect place to stop for some food after riding your bike or before attending a Brewster Whitecaps baseball game.

All the pizzas at Stone L’Oven Pizza are free from additives and preservatives, and most ingredients are locally sourced. Popular items include their sweet potato and bacon, meat lover, buffalo chicken, and Greek pizzas, which come as 12-inch or 16-inch pies. You can also build your own pizza or order a calzone or pasta dish during your visit.

Stone L’Oven Pizza does things a little bit differently, which is why they’re a top choice in the Brewster area.

Pizza Shark

Pizza Shark is a local chain with restaurants in Dennis, Chatham, and Harwich. This Chatham location is inside the Orpheum Theater and has a bar area, making it a cool place to hang out for a few hours. You can also grab a slice or a full pie to take into the movie with you. The Harwich location is inside the Pleasant Lake General Store, making it another unique and historic spot to check out.

No matter where you order your pizza, you’ll find a great menu with items named after sharks. Some of the most popular include the megalodon, which is a meat lover’s pizza, the loan shark, featuring homemade meatballs pepperoni, mushroom, onion, and broccoli, and the nurse shark, which is a vegetarian option.

You can also create your own pizza at Pizza Shark or opt for a salad, as they have a wide variety of greens on the menu.

Pizza Barbone

If you’re checking out Main Street in Hyannis and looking for a pie, Pizza Barbone is a top choice. This trendy restaurant has a wood-fired pizza oven and makes authentic Neapolitan pizzas, which you’re sure to enjoy every time you stop for a bite to eat.

Menu items at Pizza Barbone include their sweet sausage, pistachio pesto, forest mushroom, soppressata, and Barbone meatball pizzas, which customers love. You can also choose from various appetizers and greens and have a cannoli for dessert at this one-of-a-kind Cape Cod restaurant.

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza is another local chain with locations in Sandwich, Chatham and Yarmouth that makes a pretty good pie. This restaurant is known for its chunky tomato sauce, which is found on popular menu items like the Rusty, the Sarah, and the meat lovers pizza.

In addition to tomato sauce, the pizzeria has various options with white sauce, including their famous clam casino pizza. This pie features clams, bacon, asiago, and garlic and is a hit with customers all over the Cape.

You can choose between various sandwiches, pasta dishes, and calzones at Sweet Tomatoes Pizza, too, if you aren’t in the mood for pizza.

Order Your Pie Today

There could be days on Cape Cod where nothing but a great pizza will cut it, and fortunately, there are plenty of excellent pizzerias to check out during your stay. As a bonus, your vacation rental will have a fridge to store your leftovers, so order as much pizza as you want because you can enjoy the rest the following day.

There’s a good chance you’ve never heard of these local Cape Cod pizza restaurants before, but all of them are worth your time on your next vacation.